88 points Wine Spectator: "[$20 list] Peach and passion fruit flavors, with citrus notes and plenty of spice, make this a fresh-tasting quaff. Ripe apple notes, with hints of pie crust, chimes in on the finish. Drink now through 2018. (11/30/10)"

88 points David Schildknecht (Wine Advocate): "[$20 list] Fig, very ripe peach, passion fruit, and decadent lily scent von Buhl’s 2009 Riesling Kabinett Armand -- a significant portion of which came from the Kieselberg -- and while it is rather soft in feel as well as obvious in its sweetness, there are a hint of tingling brightness; a lick of salt; and a nip of ginger that keep the considerable finish enticing of the next sip. This ought to remain delightful for at least 4-5 years. (Feb 2011)"

88 points Fine Wine Review: "The Armand Kabinett is lively, nervy, off dry, and quite round. It is a good wine for drinking young. (Issue #131/132; 2011)"