93 points Wine & Spirits: "Despite the sweet and delicate face of the Emperatriz on the label, this is one of the richest and most concentrated Sherries in the Lustau portfolio. Aromas of caramelized plum and nuts dominate, a chalkier scent in the background. Generous and round, it feels almost oily and thick, the chalky element giving tension, cutting the sweetness and adding an intriguing complexity. Great Oloroso. (Jun 2006)"

92 points Jay Miller (Wine Advocate): "The non-vintage Oloroso de Jerez 'Emperatriz Eugenia' ratchets up the intensity. Because it is relatively dry, it is also a good match with savory foods. (Feb 2007)"