97 points David Schildknecht (Wine Advocate): "It's a Kabinett and Spatlese vintage, and there don't have to be Auslesen, besides which the world has enough Auslesen right now from recent years in which what used to be special has become routine, says Donnhoff by way of introducing the 2008 Oberhauser Brucke Riesling Eiswein A.P. #21. But we left just a few bunches hanging in the Brucke, he continues, because they were in such stable health. It got to be December and I though oh dear! I'd promised the family I would not spoil the holidays. Finally, on the 30th of December, conditions were perfect for Eiswein.- Scents of radish, lemon zest, and apricot preserves along with an ominously smoky prickle in the nose usher in a palate of Eszencia-like viscosity, apricot nectar concentration, delicacy (at only 7% alcohol) and complete absence of superficial sweetness. This finishes with piercing intensity and dazzling complexity, adding black tea; sea salt; ginger; seedy, tart red raspberry; and honey to the apricot jam and lemon. It's like a razor-sharp saber slathered in oily, ambrosial jelly and suspended in mid air. Few if any Eiswein of the vintage approach this for intricacy, refinement, or classic Eiswein character. I expect whatever portion of its 300 liters that is not drunk sooner to astound for at least two and perhaps three decades. (Feb 2010)"

96+ points John Gilman (View From the Cellar): "There are two distinct Eisweins from the Oberhäuser Brücke in 2008, with one harvest on December 30th and the second one harvested the next day on New Year’s Eve. This note is taken from the one harvested on the 30th, which was still gently fermenting away in the cellars at the time of my visit in the third week of April of this year. The bouquet is a haunting blend of apple, caramel, oranges, slate, honey, hints of new leather and a bit of candied grapefruit in the upper register. On the palate the wine is mediumfull, deep, pure and racy, with stunning cut and focus on the very long, racy and laser-like finish. This will be a great bottle of Eiswein. 2012-2035. (Mar/Apr 2009)"