91 points Wine News: "Deep salmon hue. Pretty nose with caramel, brown sugar and baked apple scents. Flavors of mocha and caramel with strawberry hints. Tart close with red fruit highlights and the backing of fresh acidity. (Dec 2007/Jan 2008)"

'Editors' Choice' and 90 points Wine Enthusiast: "[$27 list] A beautiful rosé sparkling wine, one that shows loads of finesse and elegance. But the final word is its deliciousness. Really captivates with subtle raspberry, toast, vanilla and yeasty brioche flavors that finish so crisp and clean. (Dec 2010)"

90 points Robert Parker: "Even better, the Non-Vintage Mirabelle Brut Rose (58% Chardonnay and 42% Pinot Noir) exhibits a light to medium pink color as well as abundant aromas of kir, medium body, good vibrancy and a crisp, zesty, dry finish. These cuvees are meant to be drunk upon release as there is no point in aging them. (12/23/2010)"